Reviews is a collection of game reviews of MEPBM and its various modules.
- 4th Age Problems by Alan H., News from Bree, Issue #11, August 2001
- Battle of the Five Armies: A New MEPBM Scenario based on 'The Hobbit', Part 1 by Jefferey Dobberpuhl and Scott Moyes, Flagship Magazine, Issue #99, December / January 2002-2003
- Battle of the Five Armies: A New MEPBM Scenario based on 'The Hobbit', Part 2 by Jefferey Dobberpuhl and Scott Moyes, Flagship Magazine, Issue #102, April / May 2003
- Confessions of a Middle Earth Virgin by Steve Mason, News from Bree, Issue #2, January 1999
- A Fourth Age Review by Gavin Kenny, News from Bree, Issue #4, June 1999
- A Fourth Age Review: part 1 by Richard Devereux, News from Bree, Issue #5, August 1999
- A Fourth Age Review: part 2 by Richard Devereux, News from Bree, Issue #6, December 1999
- Maiden Voyage by Heidi Wolters, News from Bree, Issue #31, August 2006
- Maiden Voyage Part II by Heidi Wolters, News from Bree, Issue #32, December 2006
- Middle Earth PBM: Meeting a Challenge by Darren Hayward, Flagship Magazine, Isssue #95, February / March 2002
- Middle Earth Play-by-Mail Review by Len Scensny, Paper Mayhem, Issue #57, November/December 1992
- There and Back Again: A MEPBM Player's Tale by DJ Barry, Jr., Suspense & Decision, Issue #10, Aug 2014 - Sep 2015
- The Triumph of Sauron by Richard Devereux, Flagship Magazine, Issue #112, February / March 2005