Game Diaries is a collection of completed games summaries and stories.
- A Lost Cause (or how the Ice King Bit It in 7 turns in game 101) by Nunya B. Sness, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #23
- Anatomy of a Game: The First Eight Turns by Tom Walton and Brian Mason, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #42
- Battle of the Five Armies: Head to Head by Jeff Dobberpuhl & Scott Moyes, News from Bree, Issue #20, December 2002
- Battle of the Five Armies: Head to Head: Part 2 by Jeffery Dobberpuhl & Scott Moyes, News from Bree, Issue #21, February 2003
- Cardiff FtF: a GM's-Eye View FtF VII, Cardiff, May 2005 by Clint Oldridge, News from Bree, Issue #29, September 2005
- Cardiff FtF: A myopic view from a FTF newbie by Mike Barber, News from Bree, Issue #29, September 2005
- Diary of a Fourth Age Game by James Spalding, News from Bree, Issue #7, February 2000
- A Diary of a Three Way International Fourth Age Grudge Match by Harlequin Games, News from Bree, Issue #3, April 1999
- Face to Face Middle Earth! by Colin Forbes, News from Bree, Issue #7, February 2000
- The Flagship Challenge Cup by Mike Sankey, News from Bree, Issue #33, March 2007
- The "From the Mouth of Sauron" 2950 game Rogues Gallery (2950/22), Part I, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #26
- The "From the Mouth of Sauron" 2950 game Rogues Gallery (2950/22), Part II, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #27
- The "From the Mouth of Sauron" 2950 game Rogues Gallery (2950/22), Part III, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #28
- Game 5 (UK) by The truth is told... by Colin Forbes, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #34
- Game 22 - lessons learned about "grudge matches" by Dave Holt, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #29
- Game 32 Reports by John Abbot & Michael Blomquist, News from Bree, Issue #38, 25 January 2018
- Game 42: Oh for a Palantir by Jeremy Richman, GSI Website, 8 November 2018
- Game 52 Report by Clint Oldridge, GSI, 11 December 2018
- Game 54 Report: Eothrain and Sotuh Gondor by David East, GSI Website, 4 January 2019
- Game 69: Free People Diary by Mike Sankey, Middle-earth Games Website, 31 August 2018
- Game 70 Report by Brendan McGoldrick, News from Bree, Issue #13, March 2002
- Game 94 Report by Kim Andersen, News from Bree, Issue #34, March 2008
- Game 115 and Team Play in Middle-Earth by Tom Walton, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #30
- Grudge Games, II: 2950/22 by Brian Mason, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #28
- Grudge Games: 2950/22 by Brian Mason, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #27
- Hall of Fame: 1650 Game 33 by Brad Brunet, News from Bree, Issue #28, March 2005
- Hall of Fame: 1650 Game 33 by Richard Devereux, News from Bree, Issue #28, March 2005
- Hall of Fame: 1650 Game 56 - Woodmen by Rick Dorsey, News from Bree, Issue #28, March 2005
- Hall of Fame: 1650, Game 56 - Quiet Avenger by Ian Etchells, News from Bree, Issue #28, March 2005
- Hall of Fame: 1650: Game 65 by Tony Ackroyd, News from Bree, Issue #17, August 2002
- Hall of Fame: 1650 Game 85 by Nic Tall, News from Bree, Issue #26, January 2004
- Hall of Fame: 1650: Game 131 by Dan Newman, News from Bree, Issue #18, September 2002
- Hall of Fame: 2950: Game 221 by Andrew Jones, News from Bree, Issue #18, September 2002
- Hall of Fame: 2950 Game 221 by Dan, News from Bree, Issue #28, March 2005
- Hall of Fame: Game 229 (2950) by Marc Pinsonneault, News from Bree, Issue #19, November 2002
- Hall of Fame: Bradford Fisher, scribe to the great Lord Hoarmurath of the Nine, tells the story of a game by Bradford Fisher, News from Bree, Issue #28, March 2005
- The Hall of Fame, The Dark Sun, issue 25 by David Murrary, News from Bree, Issue #13, March 2002
- Hall of Fame Face to Face Special: The First Game: A Captain's point of view by Andy Wright, News from Bree, Issue #24, August 2003
- Hall of Fame Face to Face Special: The Second Game by Ulrik Bisgaard, News from Bree, Issue #24, August 2003
- Hall of Fame: Flagship Challenge Cup: the story of Game 33 by Laurence G. Tilley, News from Bree, Issue #27, February 2005
- Hall of Fame: Fourth Age c1000: Game 46 by Ernie III / Bramble Queen / Graypeak Kingdom, News from Bree, Issue #17, August 2002
- Hall of Fame: Game 34 (1650 Grudge) ends in FP Victory by Jeppe Skytte Spicker, News from Bree, Issue #21, February 2003
- Hall of Fame: Game 48 - Fourth Age by Bernd Luehrsen, News from Bree, Issue #14, May 2002
- Hall of Fame: Game 48 - Fourth Age by Alan J., News from Bree, Issue #15, June 2002
- Hall of Fame: Game 51 (1650) ends in DS Victory by Anonymous, News from Bree, Issue #21, February 2003
- Hall of Fame: Game 57 by Brian Mason, News from Bree, Issue #25, January 2004
- Hall of Fame: Game 72 by Paul Romaine, News from Bree, Issue #16, July 2002
- Hall of Fame: Game 76 - Endor falls to Darkness by Jeppe Skytte Spicker, News from Bree, Issue #25, January 2004
- Hall of Fame: Game 83 (1650) ends in FP Victory by Jeppe Skytte Spicker, News from Bree, Issue #21, February 2003
- Hall of Fame: Game 94 (TA: 1650) by Greg Shaffer, News from Bree, Issue #22, February 2003
- Hall of Fame Game 95 Gunboat Special: Dragon Lord / Corsairs by Mike Sankey, News from Bree, Issue #23, June 2003
- Hall of Fame Game 95 Gunboat Special: Quiet Avenger / Fire King by Bryn Lloyd, News from Bree, Issue #23, June 2003
- Hall of Fame: Game 142 (FA: 1000) by Paul Scheel, News from Bree, Issue #22, February 2003
- Hall of Fame: Game 228 (2950): Khazad rule ok by Richard, News from Bree, Issue #20, December 2002
- Hall of Fame: Game 234 (TA: 2950) by Garrett Love, News from Bree, Issue #22, February 2003
- Hall of Fame: Guboat game 18 (1650), and General Gunboat Commentary by Greg Shaffer, News from Bree, Issue #27, February 2005
- Hall of Fame: ME 73 report or, Invisible Man blows Clouds away by Richard Devereux, News from Bree, Issue #25, January 2004
- Hall of Fame: War of the Ring, game 234 by Darrell Shimel, News from Bree, Issue #26, January 2004
- An International Challenge: The story of (US) game 42 by Rob Pegg, News from Bree, Issue #9, May 2001
- January FtF Game by Clint Oldridge, News from Bree, Issue #26, January 2004
- Las Vegas 2019: Dark Servants: Game Diary by John Abbott, 11 July 2019
- Las Vegas 2019: Thoughts from an Organiser by Raven Zachary, 11 July 2019
- Las Vegas 2019: Through the Eyes of a Noob by Jason Bock, 11 July 2019
- Las Vegas 2019: View from the GM’s Tower: Game Diary by Clint Oldridge, 11 July 2019
- ME 180 - An Unhappy Ending by Jim Drysdale, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #45
- On an Autralian (sic) Game: 2 by Ken Lee, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #43
- Play-by-Flash-Drive: Face-to-Face Middle-earth PBM Gaming in Las Vegas by Raven Zachary, Suspense & Decision, Issue #18, August 2019
- Player Roster List for Game 22 by Brian Mason, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #29
- Reunited Arnor: The Story Continues by Brian Mason and Tom Walton, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #43
- Rules of War by Anonymous, News from Bree, Issue #31, August 2006
- The Saga of KS 649 by Michael Blomquist, Middle-earth Games Website, 28 November 2018
- Team play wins out: The story of game 35 continues by Colin Forbes, News from Bree, Issue #9, May 2001
- The Untold War of the Ring: Face to Face Game: Report from the Free People by Clint Oldridge, News from Bree, Issue #35, May 2008
- Victory through Team Play: The story of game 35 concludes by Colin Forbes, News from Bree, Issue #10, July 2001
- Victory through the Eyes of Evil by Greg Shaffer, News from Bree, Issue #12, October 2001
- The War for Middle-earth: The Agent Rings by John Abbott, GSI Website, 25 January 2018
- War of the Ring: Two Views on this New Scenario by Richard Devereux & Marc Pinsonneault, News from Bree, Issue #13, March 2002
- What Fun I could Have Had if I had Stayed In? by Ronald C. Cudworth, From the Mouth of Sauron, Issue #24